The Seattle Times has come out against a lawsuit that aims, once again, to shutter charter schools in Washington. In an editorial, the paper calls the legal battle "an unwelcome distraction from the real education work that must be accomplished" in the Evergreen State — such as improving public school funding.
Washington’s nascent charter-school system needs a chance to grow and thrive. Children in high-poverty areas need the kind of alternatives that these new public schools offer. Charter schools have more latitude to try new things — from releasing high-school students into their communities for special projects, to longer school years and more class time for kids struggling to catch up with their peers.
All schools in Washington state could someday benefit from the ideas incubating in charter schools.
The new suit threatens 12 schools — eight existing ones, and four slated to open in the fall of 2017 — that the paper argues could ultimately benefit the broader public education system. Earlier this year, after the Supreme Court found state funding for those schools unconstitutional, their supporters rallied to secure bipartisan support for a legislative funding fix that passed by a slim margin, received a lukewarm go-ahead from Gov. Jay Inslee, and allowed them to stay open. The lawsuit argues the new mechanism for funding charter schools amounts to an unconstitutional "shell game."
The fight in Washington, and the desire among charter advocates for peaceful coexistence, illustrate why education reformers spend so much time courting their strongest critics.
Jay P. Greene, who heads the University of Arkansas' Department of Education Reform, critiques this tendency on his blog, arguing education reformers need a political science lesson. Among other things, he writes, they should stop propping up their opponents by sending them grant money or giving them a platform for their views. To pass school choice-friendly policies, he argues, they need to win the support of a majority of lawmakers, most of whom will likely be Republicans. As educational options grow, so will the constituency of parents and educators who will fight to preserve and strengthen them. Presumably, the support base will broaden over time.
The battle to save Washington's charter schools, however, required the support of at least some Democrats, and the tacit acceptance of others, including Inslee and the legislative leaders who brought the bill up for a vote. Charter advocates there, like school choice backers everywhere, hope to reach a point where education options become broadly accepted, and no longer have to fight for the right simply to exist. To do that, they'll have to win over some unlikely allies, or at least convince some of their opponents (like the plaintiffs in the new lawsuit) to lay down their arms. Greene raises an important question: Is that realistic?